CITY ATTORNEY WILL TREVINO TOSSES JUDGE ART MCDONALD UNDER THE BUS
People need to know in my case against the COB, the municipal league has refused representation. Will Treviño originally asked for time to wait for an answer from the municipal league. Well, they answered and are refusing representation. Given their insurance company has denied representation, even under a letter of reservation, raises serious exposure issues against the city. My settlement offer which includes the city spending not a penny in a final settlement raises serious questions about exposure to the city. I have agreed the city can recover every penny in the cost of completing the inspection they lied about if paid for by Texas Lone Star. Who turns down such an offer?
Judge McDonald consistently runs from cases he deems too political. Not this one: If he recuses himself, I will file a mandamus to compel him to remain on the case.
THE RULE: "B.
Adjudicative Responsibilities.
(1) A judge shall hear and decide matters assigned to the judge except those in which
disqualification is required or recusal is appropriate."
In my case against the City of Brownsville Judge McDonald is by no means disqualified, and I certainly have no basis to seek his recusal. I am the one arguing he keep the case. Based on my experience I have every reason to believe he will recuse himself without any basis in law, and at great expense to the taxpayers.
I have cooperated with Will Trevino since day one. After the city filed a frivolous answer, I still offered the city the best settlement offer possible. The city falsified its document it inspected my home after AC repairs. It is by no doubt a falsified document.
Then mayor Trey Mendez, and now Mayor Cowen, and City manager Ramirez, refused to take action against Omar Ochoa for falsifying the inspection document. All three will be deposed even though I offered the best settlement offer possible.
FIRST JUDGE MCDONALD
In the same way county attorney Juan Gonzalez requested Art McDonald ignore the law and grant a court reporter immunity, Will Treviño is asking Judge McDonald grant immunity in a suit in ultra vires, against Omar Ochoa. It is a frivolous request which should be met with sanctions.
The question is why is the county and city attorneys so willing to ask Art McDonald to grant immunity where none lies? Answer: Art McDonald is very reliable when it comes time to protect the county and city.
The ultra vires doctrine is a narrow exception to governmental immunity, under which a claimant may sue a government official for injunctive relief if the official has either acted without legal authority or failed to perform a ministerial duty. City of El Paso v. Heinrich, 284 S.W.3d 366, 372 (Tex. 2009)
MY SETTLEMENT OFFER WHICH THE CITY HAS NOW REJECTED
There is an issue that my AC system may catch fire, which voids the homeowner's policy. I have a duty to replace the AC closet, and have the new AC properly inspected. The city never inspected the unit, while passing it. Will Treviño appears to be defending this policy by the city.
My offer was simple; The city sends an inspector to my home to determine what needs to be done to allow for a proper inspection. As the picture below shows, the AC unit cannot be accessed or inspected because of how the closet was installed. Texas Lone Star has already been sanctioned by the state $11,250.00, for its abuses. These are findings as a matter of law which the owner of Texas Lone Star has signed off on under a consent decree. There is no dispute.
All I wanted was for the city to remove the bad closet, install the new closet, and then perform a proper inspection once it had access to the AC unit. It could not do this when installed because the closet made it impossible to access the AC unit.
I did not ask for a penny more. With a proper inspection Texas Lone Star and its bonding company would have to pay.
I agreed that to the extent Texas Lone Star paid to replace the closet, I would agree to refund the city its cost of replacing the closet so it could complete the inspection. I am actually telling the city if by agreement or judgment Texas Lone Star pays to replace the closet, the city will get the money as a refund. There is no better deal on the planet.
I am asking the city's answer to be struck for its frivolous claim Omar Ochoa is immune from suit. If Art McDonald tries to recuse himself, I will seek mandamus review to compel him to keep the case. He will not be allowed to run from this case because it is political, and he is up for reelection.
THE CONSEQUENCES TO THE CITY ARE REAL
The city is trying to paint itself as friendly to expansion and construction. Will Treviño in court pleadings is suggesting the city has discretion in whether it will enforce the building code. This is the same old problem, Trevino's' task is to obstruct the process, without any concern as to its consequences.
A public airing of what happened in my home is how the city will handle code enforcement will not bode well for the COB. The good news for the city is, no matter how good the visuals are in my case, no news media will accept the story. No one locally will cross the city. This story does not go beyond the city, so unlike John Doe's case, no outside news service has an interest.
First Art McDonald recused himself in the case of Josefina Fischer rather than dismiss the criminal charges against her as frivolous. The visiting judge had no problem dismissing the criminal case. Then in the case of the court reporter Judge McDonald recused himself rather than sanction the county for claiming court reporters are subject to immunity when they are not. And now the question is raised will he recuse himself in my case against the city rather than sanction the city for its frivolous pleadings on the same issue of immunity.
It is also to be understood; the city is demanding a hearing on Special Exceptions before Texas Lone Star answers the lawsuit. This is a major increase in the cost of litigation. It is a major unethical delay tactic. To the extent I must amend the lawsuit, I will have to pay to have Texas Lone Star served a second time, since they have failed to file an answer to date. This starts the clock again, which gives Texas Lone Star more time to file an answer. This is a major waste of time and expense. But Will Treviño does it because he expects Art McDonald to ignore the rules of professional conduct, and to ignore Will Treviño's unethical conduct.
Will is also asking the court grant special exceptions on questions of law. This is highly unethical.
Finally, Will Treviño did not include a certificate of conference that he conferred with me on the questions, and no resolution could be found so it is presented to the court for resolution. Again, this is highly unethical.
SO NOW A SIMPLE CASE WITH A FAIR SETTLEMENT OFFER WILL BECOME A NIGHTMARE FOR ART MCDONALD AS HE REFUSES TO ENFORCE THE RULES OF PROFESSIONAL CONDUCT
In my case I will fight hard to force McDonald stay on the case so he can be held accountable when he fails to do his job.
Picture of the closet and freon line the COB passed. So the record is clear, both pictures were attached as exhibits to the lawsuit. Will Treviño knows the problem and plays the delay game because his experience teaches him, ethics has no place in Cameron County courts.
All developers will know in the City of Brownsville they cannot rely on the COB to enforce the building code. If I can get a local news service to come to my home, the City Commission and Helen Ramirez will by humiliated when they cannot defend this very poor workmanship.
The city is claiming they do not know which code violations I am alleging. They have their own findings, which is plead, they have the state sanction against Texas Lone Star, they have these pictures, they have my complaints to Trey Mendez, and Helen Ramirez, and since John Cowen came to office, he has all complaints.
I feel bad for Trey because his duty still remains to the city, and they can toss him under the bus. His hands are tied to cooperate with John Cowen and Helen Ramirez.